America’s Cup defender hit with ‘unprecedented penalties’

Posted on

ac0904The International Jury for the America’s Cup levied multiple penalties on Oracle Team USA on Tuesday for modifications the syndicate made to its AC45 catamarans in 2012.

Three members of the American syndicate, headed by software billionaire Larry Ellison, have been excluded from the America’s Cup Finals: Dirk de Ridder, the wingsail trimmer and a leading member of Oracle’s crew; and shore-crew members Andy Walker and Bryce Ruthenberg. Matt Mitchell, another of the team’s sailors, was barred from the first four races. Oracle Team USA also has been docked two points in the Cup Finals, which begin Saturday, and fined $250,000.

“The rules infractions involved only a few of our 130 team members and were done without the knowledge of either our team’s management or the skippers who were driving the boats,” team CEO Russell Coutts said in a statement. “While we disagree with the unprecedented penalties imposed by the jury, we have no choice but to make the necessary changes to personnel on our raceboat and do our best to use the next four days for the new team to practice and get ready for the start of the 34th America’s Cup.”

The penalty was assessed because of a rules breach in early 2012 that involved  modifications — adding weight and altering boat parts without the approval of class measurers — to the AC45 cats Oracle Team USA sailed in the preliminary America’s Cup World Series, not the larger AC72 cats sailed in the America’s Cup. In August, the team voluntarily withdrew retroactively from the 2012-13 regattas that involved the AC45s.

The International Jury confirmed that only a handful of people were involved and concluded that all of the senior management of Oracle Team USA — including skippers Jimmy Spithill and Ben Ainslie, CEO Russell Coutts, general manager Grant Simmer and shore team director Mark Turner — were not aware or involved in any way.

To win the America’s Cup a team must score nine points, the highest number in the 162-year history of the competition. However, the defending Oracle Team USA now must win 11 races to retain the trophy. Emirates Team New Zealand, the challenger, is unaffected and must win nine races.

Click here for the full announcement of the ruling.

The ruling is another bit of unwanted publicity for the famed regatta. In May, the Swedish team Artemis’ AC72 capsized during training with the death of crewmember Andrew Simpson.

On the eve of the Oracle ruling, renowned Cup historian Bob Fisher gave a scathing interview on the state of the race and criticized the switch to multihulls.

“I’m a catamaran enthusiast. I think they are great boats, but they are no use to the America’s Cup,” Fisher told the New Zealand news outlet

“This isn’t yacht racing; this is display racing for television. It was made for television and declared made for television. If I have to give a man of the match award I give it to [graphics guru] Stan Honey for what he has done on the electronics, because they are absolutely stupendous. Anyone can follow it, but what are we following?”


2 comments on “America’s Cup defender hit with ‘unprecedented penalties’

  1. ediva

    While non-traditional, the people I interact with find the racing more exciting and interesting than anything in the 162 year history.
    What they find appalling is the lack of US born sailors on any of the boats included the “Team USA” Oracle. So if the US loses the race, who (in the USA) cares…What started out as a race of countrymen, until the cup left Newport, RI, is still all about the ego of the richest millionaire. I will still watch because as mentioned above, the growth in electronic technology is mesmerizing, so at least we have something to gain from this.

  2. chris

    Is that scoring really correct? If Oracle start on -2 and there are only 17 races at 1 point each, surely TNZ cannot be beaten if they get to 8 points… by then, Oracle could only get to 7 points even if they won all the remaining 9 races… Or is it that TNZ still have to get to 9, even though by then Oracle could only get to 6 points, which would not make it much of a penalty…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. For more information, please see our Comments Policy.

Vote Today

What's most important to you when it comes to the federal budget?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Login to Trade Only Today

Lost Password