Electrical deaths raise awareness as summer starts

Posted on Written by Eric Colby
Take precautions before letting your family jump into the water near any dock that has electrical power.

Take precautions before letting your family jump into the water near any dock that has electrical power.

Last weekend an 11-year-old girl in New Jersey and a 19-year-old man in Ohio were killed while participating in a seemingly harmless activity — swimming near a boat dock.

Local news reports said the girl died when she touched an electrified boat lift. The young man in Ohio died from electrical current in the water. He was trying to save his father and the family dog, who also were struggling with the electrical current.

Swimming deaths from electricity fall into two catgeories: electrocution and electric shock drowning. Electrocution can happen in fresh water or salt water when a swimmer touches energized metal dock fittings, boats or other structures that are energized because of faulty alternating current wiring.

ESD occurs when alternating current gets into fresh water from faulty wiring and the current passes through a swimmer, causing paralysis or even death. In the case of ESD a swimmer does not need to be touching anything and small amounts of electricity can be incapacitating.

American Boat and Yacht Council president John Adey said more people need to be made aware of the dangers of bad dock wiring practices and the key to electrical safety around the water is ground-fault protection.

“It all comes down to some type of ground fault device whenever you have electricity near the water,” he said. “They have to be in the circuit.”

The ABYC’s standard E-11 “AC & DC Electrical Systems on Boats” calls for a full ground-fault protection scheme on boats.

The ABYC’s standards end with the outlet that a shore-power cord is plugged into. The regulations for the dock side of the equation come from the National Electrical Code, and Article 555 focuses on “Marinas, Boatyards and Commercial and Noncommercial Docking Facilities.”

It calls for ground-fault protection and overcurrent protection devices at the mains, feeders and branch circuits and recommends that warning signs be installed at all approaches to docks where electrical wiring and equipment is installed.”

BoatUS said the risk of ESD is greatest in fresh or brackish water, so some bodies of water, such as estuaries or rivers, may be considered dangerous only after heavy rains. In salt water, electricity takes the path of least resistance.

Drowning swimmers usually can’t call for help because their mouth is mostly underwater. An ESD victim can appear confused about what is happening and may be able to shout while feeling numbness, tingling, pain or even paralysis.

To prevent electrocution or ESD, BoatUS recommends the following:

*  Never swim around docks that use electricity

*  Post “No Swimming” signs

*  Have a qualified electrician with experience in dock electrical service inspect your private dock annually

*  Install ground-fault protection on your boat and private dock

*  Make sure your marina has installed ground-fault protection and that the electrical system is inspected, and test annually in case someone falls overboard; no one should swim in a marina

*  Test your boat for electrical leakage into the water.

BoatUS also suggests that if you see a distressed person in the water near a dock, don’t jump in. First shut off power to the dock at the breaker and, if equipped, disconnect any power cable to the vessel.

If the power cannot be shut down, follow the “reach, throw, row, but don’t go” mantra by using an oar or boathook to reach the victim or throw a flotation device to the stricken person.


4 comments on “Electrical deaths raise awareness as summer starts

  1. Mitchell Jones

    Look….both of these are unfortunate and all too common. Neither happened near a marina. Marinas are doing their part and we need private dock owners and boat owners to do their part.

  2. David Rifkin

    The majority of marinas DO NOT comply with current standards. And the standards are NOT retroactive, and up to authorities having jurisdiction to be the referee (they ultimately rule on what might considered retroactive or not).

    The voltage detection devices are fine as long as the are NOT used as a “green light” for swimming. NO SWIMMING is the first line of defense. Very risky once in the water….


  3. William Drake

    I have served on both the ABYC and NFPA electrical committees, and both organizations have reacted to the ESD problem by enacting requirements to sense and cutoff power when a hazard arises. Unfortunately, as Mr. Rifkin points out, standards are not retroactive.

    The hazard in marinas is similar to the hazard in bathrooms before ground-fault circuit-interrupters (GFCI’s) became widely used. It will be years before the safety provisions are widely installed, but we must keep pushing, pushing, pushing for upgrades.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. For more information, please see our Comments Policy.

Vote Today

What's your favorite month on the water?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Login to Trade Only Today

Lost Password