Skip to main content

Should Coast Guard have scuttled life jacket rule?

  • Author:
  • Updated:
    Original:

In March, the Coast Guard published a rule that could improve the development of inflatable life jackets and lead to new international standards. Last week, the Coast Guard abruptly withdrew the rule because it got a letter – one letter - opposing it.

If you’re thinking that’s not typical for the Coast Guard, you’re right. But it really highlights the fiasco the whole subject of life jackets has become, especially in light of the Coast Guard’s desire for a national mandate to wear life jackets. Just as the Coast Guard pulled the plug on a good proposal regarding inflatables, perhaps it should also do the same for the very unpopular idea of mandatory wear.

In withdrawing the rule on inflatable life jackets, the Coast Guard sank what was intended to lead to new standards for possible wear by boaters younger than 16 years old (currently prohibited.) In March, the Coast Guard put into the Federal Register: “Although the Coast Guard is not yet ready to revisit the issue of inflatables (personal flotation devices) for children, the industry has begun … to explore the appropriateness of these devices for children and create an appropriate standard." To support development of new international standards for children under 16, the Coast Guard needed to eliminate the words “approved for use by adults only” from the current regulations.

That’s what drew fire from Susan Balistreri, of Balistreri Consulting Inc., reportedly a consultant for life jacket design. She claimed the proposed rule was a move to allow teenagers to use inflatables designed for adults. She claims younger boaters don’t have the capacity to use inflatables properly, a position that is likely rejected by many others in boating safety as well as the boating public. But, it seems clear she also knew that her one objection would likely cause the Coast Guard to start over by having to go through the full rulemaking requirements, including public comments, etc.

The Coast Guard should initiate the necessary rulemaking without delay. In fact, it should have stood its ground in the first place. After all, it proposed the rule knowing full well that life jackets would still have to meet all existing standards including those that limit the use of inflatables to teens 16 and up. Moreover, it’s a paradox that the Coast Guard is pushing for mandatory wear - in spite of surveys like those of BoatUS that reveal boaters overwhelmingly oppose a mandatory rule - but doesn’t dig heels in for a much-needed rule change leading to new standards that could result in increased life jacket wear.

Perhaps it’s also a good time to revisit and update the mandatory wear issue, including the Army Corps of Engineers’ mandated wear program on California’s Pine Flat Lake and the actions of the Boating Safety Advisory Council. We’ll do it all in next Tuesday’s Dealer Outlook.

Related

VOLVO-EARNINGS

Volvo Penta Reports Q4, FY22 Results

Net sales of $470 million for the quarter were a 33% increase compared to the prior year period.

Pulse-Report

DEALERS: Are You Improving the Service Experience?

Our monthly Pulse Report survey asks this and other questions about your dealership. Take the survey here.

NMRA-SCHOLARSHIP

NMRA Sets Scholarship Deadline

Students pursuing education in the marine trades can apply for the National Marine Representatives Association awards until April 1.

MARINE-PRODUCTS

Marine Products Reports Record Q4

The builder of Chaparral and Robalo boats reported net sales were up 42% for the quarter and 28% for fiscal year 2022.

1_SHURHOLD

Shurhold Appoints COO

Forrest Ferrari has years of management, business development, IT and quality-assurance experience.

MOBILE-CATCH-CENTER

RBFF, Pure Fishing Partner for a First Catch Center

Pure Fishing will equip a mobile trailer with tackle and gear to bring fishing experiences to areas of South Carolina where participation is low.

Norm

An Oft-Overlooked Sales Opportunity

A recent report from the Recreational Boating & Fishing Foundation showed that women comprise 37% of all anglers. If you haven’t tapped this segment, you’re missing out.

1. 2023 new boat retail outlook

Too Many High-Priced Boats

To wrap up 2022, marine retailers reported lower demand, expressed more negative sentiment and voiced concerns about rising inventory. Boat prices and the economy remained top of mind for dealers in December.

Soundings Nov 2022

New-Boat Registrations Continue to Slide

As the gaudy sales figures from the pandemic continue to return to more realistic numbers, the main segments of the recreational boating industry saw new-model registrations of 4,421 in November, a 30.3% drop from 6,340 during the same time in 2021. .