Skip to main content

NTSB Calls for Safety Changes After Dive Boat Fire Killed 34

When rescuers arrived, Conception was completely engulfed in flames.

When rescuers arrived, Conception was completely engulfed in flames.

The National Transportation Safety Board is calling for safety changes to passenger vessels after concluding its investigation of a dive boat caught fire in California last year, killing 34 on board.

The NTSB said vessels like the Conception (with overnight accommodations) should be required to have interconnected smoke detectors in all passenger areas.

The board also recommended that a secondary means of escape lead to a different space than the primary exit in case fire blocks both escape paths, as was the case in the Sept. 2, 2019, disaster.

The 75-foot dive boat was anchored in Platt’s Harbor, off Santa Cruz Island, when it caught fire in the early morning — trapping all 33 passengers and one crew member in the berthing area while the fire raged on deck above. Both exits from the berthing area led to the fire and a smoke-filled enclosed area above.

Emergency responders tried to stabilize the vessel to tow back to the mainland when it quickly sunk. Photo courtesy of Paul Amaral, an emergency responder.

Emergency responders tried to stabilize the vessel to tow back to the mainland when it quickly sunk. Photo courtesy of Paul Amaral, an emergency responder.

Emergency responders worked to put out the fire and find survivors, but that effort quickly turned into a recovery effort for those who had died. (Read one emergency responder’s account here.)

Investigators said the absence of required roving patrols on the Conception likely delayed the initial detection of the fire, allowed for its growth, thwarted firefighting and evacuation efforts and directly led to the high number of fatalities in the accident.

That conclusion led the NTSB to call on the U.S. Coast Guard to develop and implement an inspection program to verify that roving patrols are being conducted on these types of vessels.

“The Conception may have passed all Coast Guard inspections, but that did not make it safe,” said NTSB chairman Robert Sumwalt in a statement. “Our new recommendations will make these vessels safer, but there is no rule change that can replace human vigilance.”

The recommendations to the Coast Guard would apply to vessels that are under 100 gross tons and have overnight accommodations for 49 or fewer passengers that fall under Subchapter T of federal marine regulations, like the Conception.

Responders initially planned to tow the boat elsewhere so workers could start the recovery phase, but the vessel quickly sunk before being recovered. Photo courtesy of Paul Amaral, an emergency responder.

Responders initially planned to tow the boat elsewhere so workers could start the recovery phase, but the vessel quickly sunk before being recovered. Photo courtesy of Paul Amaral, an emergency responder.

The NTSB’s recommendation on interconnected smoke detectors — meaning when one smoke detector alarms the remaining detectors also alarm — also would apply to larger Subchapter K vessels.

While the Conception had smoke detectors in the below-deck berthing area, they were not connected to each other or the wheelhouse, and there were no smoke detectors in the salon, where investigators believe the fire started.

Because of the fire damage to Conception, which burned to the water line and then sank, there was little physical evidence for investigators to establish exactly how, when and where the fire started.

The board also stressed its recommendation for small passenger vessels to be required to implement a safety management system to improve the safety culture of vessel owners and operators.

Read the full investigation report here

Related

VOLVO-EARNINGS

Volvo Penta Reports Q4, FY22 Results

Net sales of $470 million for the quarter were a 33% increase compared to the prior year period.

Pulse-Report

DEALERS: Are You Improving the Service Experience?

Our monthly Pulse Report survey asks this and other questions about your dealership. Take the survey here.

NMRA-SCHOLARSHIP

NMRA Sets Scholarship Deadline

Students pursuing education in the marine trades can apply for the National Marine Representatives Association awards until April 1.

MARINE-PRODUCTS

Marine Products Reports Record Q4

The builder of Chaparral and Robalo boats reported net sales were up 42% for the quarter and 28% for fiscal year 2022.

1_SHURHOLD

Shurhold Appoints COO

Forrest Ferrari has years of management, business development, IT and quality-assurance experience.

MOBILE-CATCH-CENTER

RBFF, Pure Fishing Partner for a First Catch Center

Pure Fishing will equip a mobile trailer with tackle and gear to bring fishing experiences to areas of South Carolina where participation is low.

Norm

An Oft-Overlooked Sales Opportunity

A recent report from the Recreational Boating & Fishing Foundation showed that women comprise 37% of all anglers. If you haven’t tapped this segment, you’re missing out.

1. 2023 new boat retail outlook

Too Many High-Priced Boats

To wrap up 2022, marine retailers reported lower demand, expressed more negative sentiment and voiced concerns about rising inventory. Boat prices and the economy remained top of mind for dealers in December.

Soundings Nov 2022

New-Boat Registrations Continue to Slide

As the gaudy sales figures from the pandemic continue to return to more realistic numbers, the main segments of the recreational boating industry saw new-model registrations of 4,421 in November, a 30.3% drop from 6,340 during the same time in 2021. .