Threat of lawsuit against EPA could affect industry


Environmental groups are threatening the Environmental Protection Agency with a lawsuit that could result in additional regulations for boatbuilders.

The Sierra Club and California Communities Against Air Toxics said in an Aug. 26 letterrecently posted to the EPA’s website that the agency failed to review toxics standards for 46 industries, including the marine industry, as required by the Clean Air Act of 1990.

According to the law, the EPA had eight years after finalizing the boatbuilder Maximum Achievable Control Technology in 2001 to perform the assessment, called a residual risk review, according to the National Marine Manufacturers Association.

The agency has yet to conduct reviews of several industries because of staffing issues, and more recently because of sequestration and budget cuts, NMMA director of environmental and safety compliance John McKnight told Trade Only Today.

“Clearly they have failed in what they were required to do under the law, so I anticipate that the courts will order them to do it,” McKnight told Trade Only.

It will take time for the matter to work its way through the court system, McKnight says.

“It’s something we need to follow closely, but it won’t be something that we need to react to immediately,” McKnight said. “But it’s important that boatbuilders are notified because ... it’s going to come and, when it comes, it’s going to be a big deal.”

The review could result in the EPA saying it thinks the current standards are adequate, McKnight said. Or it could prompt the agency to further regulate the industry by, for example, making all builders move to closed-molded technology.

“This could take it to the next phase. They could turn around and say, ‘We think MACT did a good job,’ but industry knows there’s further technological advancement out there. They’ll do a very thorough review and they might see that 60 percent of boatbuilders are using closed-molded techniques and think, ‘We think everyone can do it because this is a technology that is feasible,’” McKnight said. “Who knows what else will come down the pipe between now and then? Technology always advances.”

More regulations would mean more money spent by manufacturers to implement new technologies, he said, adding that the industry already made a big investment in 2001 when the initial law went into effect.

“I’ve been anticipating this to happen,” he said. “We were supposed to hear from the EPA on residual review in 2009 and they haven’t done anything, which is fine with me, but that’s what these environmental groups do. They’re law firms posing as environmental groups. This is, again, the government putting the microscope on our industry.”

— Reagan Haynes



Star brite introduces Marine Descaling Fluid—a powerful, easy way to descale raw water-cooled systems using recirculation. It saves time, energy, and a lot of headache, allowing for a faster, cost-effective return-to-service for equipment.

NAW Elects 2021 Officers

Michael Medart of Medart Engine and Marine takes the helm as chairman of the National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors board.

Caterpillar Names Global Manager

Alex Berg will lead the manufacturer’s pleasure craft and yachting segment.

Nearly 320K Boats Sold in 2020

NMMA says new-boat sales are at their highest level in 12 years, with all powerboat segments up 8 to 22 percent.

‘Injection of Capital’ for Cox Powertrain

The British company said it will use the $16.7 million to expand operations and ramp up production of its CXO300 diesel outboard.

Groupe Beneteau Releases Preliminary 2020 Financials

Revenues were down 15.1 percent for the 16-month period that ended Dec. 31. A full report is due next month.

A Modern Twist on Word of Mouth

The supercharged power of user-generated content.