Skip to main content

VIDEO: Investigators seek cause of Florida boat crash

As investigators pieced together one of the deadliest recreational boating accidents they’ve ever seen in South Florida, on Monday they added alcohol to the list of possible factors contributing to a crash that killed four people and injured eight more.

“After doing a thorough inventory of the vessel, we did discover evidence of alcohol on board”the Contender that was involved in the accident, Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission spokesman Jorge Pino told the Miami Herald.

He stressed that it was too early to draw any conclusions because toxicology tests on the victims are still pending.

Pino confirmed Monday that the Contender was piloted by 23-year-old Andrew Garcia, the son of a retired Miami-Dade fireboat captain who was critical of the region’s sidelining of fireboat rescue vessels.

Garcia was knocked overboard and killed in the initial collision. Two passengers, Victoria Dempsey, 20, and Kelsie Karpiak, 24, also died. Two others aboard, Catherine Payan, 24, and Samantha Rolth, were critically injured.

Pino said the Contender struck a Carrera, where passenger Jason Soleimani, 23, died on impact. Another passenger, Dayanara Arias, 39, was critically injured and remains hospitalized. Her two young daughters escaped unscathed. Other members of the Hanono family aboard the Carrera had less-serious injuries.

Eight people on the third boat, a 35-foot Boston Whaler center console, were not seriously hurt.

Pino said investigators are examining GPS navigation units, lights and other instruments on all three boats, which are impounded at the FWC facility in North Miami, to “put the pieces of the puzzle together.”

“We are downloading GPS information and taking all the physical evidence we have and documenting it,”Pino told the Miami Herald.

No charges have been filed in the accident, which happened about 10:45 p.m. Friday about 1-1/2miles southeast of Dinner Key in Coconut Grove. The crash followed the conclusion of an Independence Day fireworks display, which typically precedes a scramble as many boaters rush in different directions to various marinas.

Kevin Karpiak, who was on the Contender when his sister was killed that night, said Garcia was an experienced, safe skipper.

“He was a good fisherman. A good boat guy. He always took responsibility,”Karpiak said.

Related

BOB-CONFERENCE

MMTA Sets Date for Conference

The educational Business of Boating Conference will be held in Foxboro, Mass., with in-person and remote attendance options.

AKZONOBEL

AkzoNobel Nominates Board Member

Ben Noteboom is expected to be elected chair to succeed the retiring Nils Andersen.

MARINE-MARKETERS

Neptune Awards Adds Category

“Boat Show Marketing” will recognize promotional efforts for shows, and entries will be accepted until Dec. 18.

WOMEN-SAILING

Sailing Convention for Women Returns

Postponed during Covid, the event will include on-water training, networking opportunities and workshops.

Norm

MBIA Names Board Members

The Michigan Boating Industries Association elected four new directors and named the officers who will serve next year. Also, the 2023 schedule for “Ladies Let’s Go Fishing!” is taking shape.

CL.YACHTS

CL Yachts Expands Dealer Network

The Hong Kong-based builder added retail locations in Australia, Dubai, Singapore and Macau.

LEGEND.BOAT.FIX

Legend Boats Partners With Boat Fix

The Canadian builder will offer the telematics system, which provides tracking, monitoring and 24-7 service, on new models starting next year.

MARINEMAX

MarineMax Establishes Technology Division

The company’s Boatyard and Boatzon units will operate under the new entity, New Wave Innovations.

SUNTEX

Suntex Purchases New Jersey Facility

Green Cove Marina in Brick is the company’s latest acquisition on the Jersey Shore, joining Channel Club Marina and Key Harbor Marina.