MasterCraft appeals boat design verdict

Author:
Updated:
Original:

MasterCraft officially filed its notice of appeal in a case that resulted in a more than $30 million judgment against the boatbuilder.

"MasterCraft has filed a notice of appeal with the Butte County (Calif.) Superior Court on Sept. 14, 2011. This is the first step in appealing the verdict in Bell v. Mastercraft Boat Company, et al. MasterCraft believes that the verdict was the result of a flawed trial and is not supported by the law or the facts. It is Mastercraft's hope that the California Court of Appeals will overturn this unjust outcome,” attorney Walt Millar said in a statement.

The appeal will be heard in the Third District Court of Appeals in Sacramento, Calif.

Last month, a Superior Court judge rejected MasterCraft's request for a new trial.

A jury ruled in June that MasterCraft was 80 percent at fault in a July 9, 2006, accident in which Niki Bell and Bethany Mercer, formerly Wallenburg, were swept off a MasterCraft X-45 wakeboarding boat and struck by its propeller. Jurors found that the driver, Jerry Montz, was 20 percent at fault. Montz admitted to drinking alcohol on the day of the accident, and there were more passengers on the boat than the manufacturer recommended.

The jury awarded $30.9 million in damages to Bell and $530,688 to Mercer.

“We remain committed to the X-45 being a great, safe boat. It’s got a tremendous safety record. It’s fully compliant with NMMA, ABYC and the U.S. Coast Guard,” John Dorton, president and CEO of MasterCraft, previously told Soundings Trade Only.

“The [plaintiff ’s attorneys] see this as a case of as someone trying to go after what’s perceived as deep pockets. No one in the marine industry has deep pockets anymore,” he said. “I think any reasonable boater understands that this is a ridiculous verdict.”

Related

Federal Government Approves Vineyard Wind

The first major wind farm in federal waters could power 400,000 New England homes, but fishing interests oppose the project.

Sea Tow Forecasts Another Busy Summer

The company had a 34 percent increase in assistance requests last summer, and the results of a survey found that people will continue to take to the water amid the pandemic.

NMMA Urges Action on E.U. Tariff

The 25 percent retaliatory tariff on American-built boats and engines, resulting in a 42 percent decline in exports to the European Union, is set to double June 1.

Brunswick’s Electrified, Connected Future

During the annual Investors Day, the company revealed its “Next Wave” strategic plan, which includes five electric propulsion products and a new boat brand by 2023.

MasterCraft Delivers Third Consecutive Record Quarter

Net sales, gross profit and net income all saw significant jumps in the third quarter, and the builder raised its fiscal-year outlook.

MRAA Board Contributes to BoatPAC

Every board member contributed to the non-partisan political action committee, which works with congressional members who recognize the importance of boating.

Educator Training Conference Agenda Announced

The ABYC Foundation’s virtual conference is scheduled for July 20-22, with speakers covering a host of topics around creating the future workforce.

RIMTA Awarded $30K Grant

The financial support will go toward its fiberglass boat recycling pilot project.

Sandy Hook Yacht Sales adds Intrepid

The dealership and brokerage firm has six locations in New Jersey and Florida.